Embracing Discomfort alongside Good Intentions

Written by Willy Oppenheim & Alex Knott
Rate this item
(0 votes)
Embracing Discomfort alongside Good Intentions Embracing Discomfort alongside Good Intentions

A recent study by The Omprakash Foundation on critical service-learning, explored the experiences of three students engaged in international volunteer programs and found that feelings of disappointment, alienation, frustration, and confusion are to be expected and even celebrated when they emerge through students’ engagements with difference.

The programs the students were involved in sought to cultivate critical consciousness. These programs, like Omprakash's EdGE, aim to encourage students to think more critically about their own positionality and the root causes of the social issues that they (and the host organizations they work with) seek to address. While they believe that cultivating critical consciousness is important, in this paper, they highlight two challenges that can emerge from this approach: 

1. In our experience, students who engage in deeper reflection on the implications of their intentions to ‘help others’ sometimes report feeling a sense of frustration, alienation, discomfort, and deflation rather than a sense of success or satisfaction at having ‘helped.’
2. In some cases, students end up directing their frustrations towards the work of their own host organizations, especially when they perceive these organizations to be providing ‘band-aid’ solutions rather than addressing the root causes.

The research focuses on three case studies reflect on the following scenarios: "Corruption is Deeply Cultural": Student Conflates Structural Violence and Cultural Difference; "Outsiders": Student Reflections on Positionality and Local Authority "Just Filling in the Gaps": Student Reflections on Organizational Sustainability and Efficacy. You can access the full article in Impact's Summer 2019 Journal

They concluded that:

Rather than providing volunteers with answers, solutions, and a self-congratulatory opportunity to ‘give back,’ critical service-learning demands that students ask more questions, challenge themselves, and realize the shortcomings of attempts to ‘help others’ without a radical change to global structures of power. To some extent, such a perspective, if internalized, is bound to leave volunteers feeling unsettled. 

The authors state that "although it is tempting to want to prevent or protect students from feelings of disappointment, alienation, frustration, and confusion, we submit that the student emotions we have explored in these case studies are to be expected and even celebrated when they emerge through students’ engagements with difference. These sentiments may even be considered evidence of students’ learning, especially insofar as our aim as critical educators is not to help students feel that they have ‘done their part,’ but rather to encourage them to realize the limits of their ability to create meaningful change without challenging dominant structures of oppression and inequality".

This realization is rarely comfortable, but we agree that "a healthy sense of discomfort about the shape of one’s world and one’s role within it is in fact a worthy learning outcome in and of itself. The bigger existential question, then, is how to help students work through this sort of discomfort with love and lightheartedness rather than allowing it to metastasize into bitterness and antagonism".


Read 3629 times

Related items

Los Pibes: La Boca beyond Instagram and Gangster films

‘Los pibes’ in Rioplatense Spanish means the kids, and that, unsurprisingly, is what this movement is dedicated to. To the children of now, but also those of the future, a future that will hopefully look different for those in the famous and infamous neighbourhood of La Boca. Whilst the ‘El caminito’ area is a hotspot for tourists who come to admire the brightly painted buildings and the street performers, according to several guidebooks and foreign travel advice pages, leaving this part of town leaves a traveller vulnerable to violent muggings.

From face-to-face volunteer to online volunteer: Sonia's testimony

Sonia volunteered a few years ago in Buenos Aires and she decided to be an online volunteer during the pandemic. Get to know more about her story here:

Through Julia's experience: What is it like to teach English as an online volunteer?

Julia tells us a little bit about her experience, what's she learning from it, and how she feels about online volunteering! Find out more in this interview:

Navigating the Pandemic: Luci's Testimony

This time we share the testimony of Luci, who describes the difficult situation in the vulnerable neighborhoods of the city of Buenos Aires. 

Navigating the Pandemic: Liliana's Testimony

We keep in touch with the organizations in the network to know how they are holding up, how the community is doing, and what challenges they see ahead.

Navigating the Pandemic: Silvia's Testimony

Social isolation keeps us apart, but the network is still active. We are talking with all the local coordinators to see how they are doing and how they see their community nowadays. Listening to the different voices in the network is part of thinking together.

Is online volunteering here to stay?

 With problems and solutions, virtuality has accelerated with the pandemic and lockdowns around the world. Within volunteering, we have worked virtually mainly in communications and teaching English. Today we want to reflect on and share this experience. 



May 4th

Login to post comments